Property Disclosure Laws in NC: What You Must Tell Buyers

"Can I just not mention the roof leak?" "Do I have to tell them about the foundation crack?" "What if I didn't know about the problem?"

I hear these questions from Newton sellers all the time. The answer is always the same: in North Carolina, you're legally required to disclose known material defects. Period.

Let me explain exactly what you must disclose, what happens if you don't, and how to protect yourself legally when selling your home.

NC Residential Property Disclosure Statement

North Carolina law requires sellers to complete a Residential Property and Owners' Association Disclosure Statement for all residential property sales.

What It Is:

• 8-page standardized form
• Lists specific questions about your property
• Must be completed honestly and completely
• Given to buyers before or at the time of offer
• Buyers have right to cancel within 3 days if not provided earlier

When Required:

• All residential property sales (1-4 units)
• New and existing construction
• Whether selling with agent or FSBO

Exemptions:

• Foreclosures
• Estate sales (some situations)
• Transfers between family members
• Court-ordered sales

If you're selling normally in Newton or Catawba County, you're filling out this form.

What Must Be Disclosed

The disclosure form asks about specific issues. You must answer honestly about anything you KNOW about.

Major Categories:

1. Structural Issues:

• Foundation cracks or settling
• Structural damage or repairs
• Roof leaks or damage
• Water intrusion
• Flood history

2. Systems and Appliances:

• HVAC system problems
• Electrical issues
• Plumbing problems
• Septic system condition
• Well water issues

3. Environmental Issues:

• Lead paint (pre-1978 homes)
• Asbestos
• Radon
• Mold
• Underground storage tanks
• Contaminated soil or water

4. Property Conditions:

• Termite or pest damage
• Drainage problems
• Boundary disputes
• Easements or rights-of-way
• HOA rules and fees

5. Other Material Facts:

• Death on property (in some cases)
• Previous fires
• Previous flooding
• Neighborhood issues
• Zoning problems

The "Known" Standard

This is critical: you must disclose defects you KNOW about.

What This Means:

You KNOW about an issue if:

• You've seen it personally
• Someone told you about it (contractor, inspector, etc.)
• It's in your maintenance records
• Previous buyers backed out because of it
• You had it repaired

You DON'T know if:

• You genuinely never noticed
• It's hidden behind walls with no symptoms
• It developed after you moved out
• You were told it was fixed properly

Example:

You had a roof leak five years ago, hired a roofer who "fixed" it, and you've had no problems since. You still must disclose the previous leak and repair.

Material vs. Minor Defects

Not every tiny flaw needs disclosure. The standard is "material defects."

Material Defect:

• Significantly affects property value
• Impacts safety or habitability
• Would influence a reasonable buyer's decision
• Costs significant money to repair

Examples of Material Defects:

• Foundation cracks
• Roof leaks
• Failing septic system
• Mold issues
• Electrical fire hazards
• Major plumbing leaks

Not Typically Material:

• Minor cosmetic issues
• Normal wear and tear
• Small nail pops
• Minor paint chips
• Squeaky doors

When in doubt, disclose it. Over-disclosure protects you legally.

Penalties for Non-Disclosure

Hiding known defects can cost you big:

Legal Consequences:

1. Buyer Can Sue

   • For cost of repairs
   • For diminished property value
   • For damages and losses
   • Potentially for punitive damages

2. Buyer Can Rescind Sale

   • Unwind the transaction
   • Get their money back
   • Force you to take house back

3. Criminal Charges (Fraud)

   • In extreme cases of intentional fraud
   • Misdemeanor or felony
   • Fines and possible jail time

Real Example:

NC seller didn't disclose significant foundation problems. Buyers discovered issues after closing, sued, and won $45,000 in damages plus attorney fees. Seller's defense: "I didn't think it was that bad." Didn't matter - they knew about it.

The "Stigmatized Property" Question

What about things that don't physically affect the property but might bother buyers?

In North Carolina:

Must Disclose:

• Pending special assessments
• HOA disputes
• Zoning violations
• Noise issues from nearby properties
• Previous flood insurance claims

Usually Don't Have to Disclose:

• Death on property (unless murder/suicide and recent)
• Previous criminal activity
• "Haunted" claims
• Previous owners' personal issues
• Neighborhood gossip

Gray Area:

• Registered sex offenders nearby (publicly available info)
• Planned developments that might affect views/traffic
• Known future neighborhood changes

When in doubt, consult a real estate attorney.

"As-Is" Sales Don't Eliminate Disclosure

Some sellers think "as-is" means they don't have to disclose. Wrong.

The Reality:

• "As-is" means you won't make repairs
• Does NOT mean you can hide known defects
• You still must complete disclosure form honestly
• Buyers still have inspection rights

"As-Is" Protects You From:

• Repair requests
• Post-inspection negotiations
• Buyer demands for updates

"As-Is" Does NOT Protect You From:

• Disclosure requirements
• Fraud claims
• Lawsuits for hidden defects

How to Protect Yourself

1. Complete Disclosure Form Thoroughly

• Answer every question
• Don't leave blanks
• Be specific about issues
• Include dates and details

2. Disclose Repairs Made

• List all major repairs
• Include contractor names if you have them
• Explain what was fixed and when
• Provide documentation if available

3. Don't Guess or Speculate

• If you don't know, write "Unknown"
• Don't make up answers
• Don't minimize problems you know about

4. Put It in Writing

• Verbal disclosures aren't enough
• Everything must be on the form or in writing
• Keep copies of all disclosures given to buyers

5. Disclose Even If Fixed

• Previous foundation crack - disclose it
• Old roof leak that's repaired - disclose it
• Mold that was professionally remediated - disclose it

6. Update If New Issues Arise

• Between disclosure and closing
• Must inform buyer of new problems
• Provide updated disclosure form

What If You Genuinely Didn't Know?

If a defect existed but you truly didn't know about it, you're usually protected.

You're Likely Protected If:

• Problem was hidden behind walls
• No visible symptoms
• No one told you about it
• Home inspector missed it too
• You lived there and had no indication

You're NOT Protected If:

• Reasonable person would have noticed
• You ignored obvious signs
• Someone told you but you "forgot"
• You closed your eyes to avoid knowing

Example:

Major termite damage hidden behind walls with no visible evidence? Probably okay if you didn't know.

Sagging floors, doors that don't close, and obvious signs of foundation issues? You knew or should have known.

Special Disclosure: Lead Paint

If your Newton home was built before 1978:

Federal Law Requires:

• Disclosure of known lead paint
• Provide EPA pamphlet to buyers
• Give buyers 10 days to test for lead (if they want)
• Violation is federal offense

Most pre-1978 homes have some lead paint. Disclose what you know, even if it's "I don't know if there's lead paint."

The Septic System Disclosure

If you have septic in Catawba County:

NC Law Requires:

• Disclose septic system location
• Disclose age and type
• Disclose known problems
• Disclose when last pumped/serviced

Smart Move:

• Get pre-sale septic inspection
• Provide report to buyers
• Shows transparency
• Reduces liability

Working With Your Agent

Your real estate agent can help with disclosures:

Agent Should:

• Provide disclosure form
• Explain requirements
• Review your completed form
• Ensure it's given to buyers timely
• Document the disclosure process

Agent Cannot:

• Complete the form for you
• Tell you to hide defects
• Make disclosure decisions
• Advise on legal matters (that's attorney's job)

When to Get Attorney Advice

Consult a real estate attorney if:

• You have significant known defects
• Previous buyers backed out due to issues
• You're unsure what must be disclosed
• You've had major repairs done
• Property has environmental issues
• You're in a complicated situation

$300-$500 for attorney advice now beats $30,000 lawsuit later.

The Cash Buyer Difference

Selling to cash buyers like us changes the disclosure dynamic:

Benefits:

• Cash buyers expect issues
• Less likely to sue over disclosed problems
• "As-is" purchase is the standard
• Faster transaction means less can go wrong

You Still Must:

• Complete disclosure form
• Be honest about known issues
• Provide form to buyer

But cash buyers are sophisticated - they know houses have issues and price accordingly.

The Bottom Line

North Carolina disclosure laws protect buyers, but they're not unfair to sellers. The rule is simple: be honest about what you know.

Key Principles:

• Disclose all known material defects
• Complete the disclosure form honestly
• Don't guess or speculate
• When in doubt, disclose
• Document everything
• Update if new issues arise

Never:

• Hide known problems
• Lie on disclosure forms
• Assume "as-is" eliminates disclosure
• Think you'll get away with it

Buyers can and do sue. North Carolina courts generally side with buyers on non-disclosure issues. Honesty isn't just the legal requirement - it's the smart play.

---

Have a Newton or Catawba County home with disclosure concerns? Contact Triton Homebuyers for a no-obligation consultation. We buy homes in any condition, with full knowledge of issues. Complete honest disclosure, and we'll make a fair offer. No risk of post-sale lawsuits or problems. Call today.